I’ve been to Pizza Cottage in Circleville quite a few times and have tried multiple items off of their menu (my favorite food being their Italian Salad), so this time I figured I’d take a chance at something I had never tried before.
We ordered one of their Signature P.L.T Subs, which is a sub topped with crispy pepperoni, provolone cheese, lettuce, roma tomatoes and mayonnaise. The sub was a pretty good even though it was a little lighter on the toppings than we’re used to. That said, the P.L.T. Sub was still a pretty good sub as far as taste goes!
The second item ordered was a Buffalo Chicken pizza, topped with buffalo wing sauce, chicken and provolone cheese. With this, you are given the choice Blue Cheese or Ranch Dressing, and my advice is that you definitely get some on the side – as this pizza is spicier than you would expect. It was an excellent, fresh pizza.
Pizza Cottage is a good place to eat if you are looking for a sit down pizza place with a nice atmosphere, and even though they cost a bit more than some other pizza joints in town it was well worth it.
I would recommend them for a Friday Pizza Night out, especially if you are looking for a place with unique pizzas. You have got to try their Loaded Baked Potato Pizza!
Pizza Cottage is located at 23401 US 23 Circleville, OH 43113.
Phone: (740) 474-3620
Dimple Dash is a monthly foodie review of restaurants located in our reading area. If you have a suggestion of someone you would like us to check out please drop us a note.
Sponsored by: Contact us to get information about becoming an advertiser.